US Supreme Court Rules Against the Idea of “Faithless Electors”

In a case that originated in Washington State, The United States Supreme Court has ruled 9-0 that State Presidential Electors – the individuals who officially cast the Electoral Votes used to determine the winner of a Presidential contest – can be punished for voting against the will of the electorate they represent, where they are otherwise known as a “Faithless Elector”.

From The Seattle Times:

The case dates back to the 2016 election, when the three electors, Bret Chiafalo, Esther “Little Dove” John and Levi Guerra, cast their electoral ballots for Colin Powell, not Hillary Clinton, in a last-ditch attempt to try to get Republican electors to abandon Donald Trump.

All of Washington’s electors had signed a pledge to support the candidate that got the most votes, so Chiafalo, John and Guerra were fined, under state law, $1,000. (A fourth Washington elector, Robert Satiacum, also broke his pledge and did not vote for Clinton, but he was not involved in the court case.)

For three and a half years, they fought that fine through the court system, all the way to the Supreme Court. At stake was much more than a $1,000 fine. Rather, it was a question that had never been definitively answered in the more than 230 years since the Electoral College was created: Can presidential electors vote for whomever they want, or can states ensure they follow voters’ will?”

The ruling will help to ensure that the will of the voters cannot be overridden by individual Electors, and that Electoral Votes are assigned properly in future Presidential Elections.

For the full progression of the case and the final opinion from the Supreme Court of the United States, follow the link HERE.

If you have any questions about access to the Federal Courts, Washington State court records, or would like information about any of our other products and services, contact us at or give us a call: 866-643-7084 (Option 2).

More From Our Blog

Monday June 3, 2024

Top 5 Issues in the Title Industry: June 2024

5 months into 2024 and already the title & real estate industries are under fire […]

Read More

Wednesday May 29, 2024

Top Legal Industry Cases: Update for 2024

The 2024 top cases are shaping up to be a doozy in the United States including […]

Read More

Friday May 24, 2024

West Coast Title Insurance Fraud: 2024 Update

Fraud is off to a quick start in the West Coast and these are the top […]

Read More